Honestly I disagree, it can compete against modern systems just you will not see it physically in terms of CPU number speed and 64 bit architecture. If we can actually do Vampire 500 Mhz 060 speed as you said then we have reached our goal. Our success will rely on super optimized coders on a 500 Mhz architecture that will make performance equivalent to that of modern system.
Well, 500Mhz probably isnt possible with the current FPGA, though it might be in future revisions.. Anyhoo, finding those coders that will code super efficient code is very hard because if they are good they have a job and as we all know, hobbyists tend to stretch their deadlines... ;-)
Look for example that guy who is making a quake engine for Atari. Have you seeing it? It is amazing coding effeciency in away you have not seeing before and it looks great, it looks like the system itself is a Pentium III with 700 Mhz when in fact it is a 68k 030 @ 30 Mhz system.
So take Vampire with 500 Mhz @ 060 and take these coders and combine them together and you will be able to get the feel of a dual process 3 Ghz Intel CPU. Which is why I am putting so much into having more RAM. RAM is the only obstacle that allows us to modernize our system back into action.
Ive seen it, and its definitely not running on the 030 alone.. he is heavily modifing the engine by exchanging floats for ints so that it can be run in parallel on the 56001 Motorola DSP. Its impressive, but such crazy guys dont come around often enough.. ;-)
By the way, I don't mind if the new standalone Amiga is only 500 mhz CPU with the cool bells and whistles of 32 bit audio or 64 bit audio (you cannot tell the difference in the human ears anyways), with build in USB, Ethernet, WifFi, blah blah blah. Still the new standalone Amiga will break the limitation of the classic hardware anyways in terms of BUS, etc. Then combine that with great programmers and you will not see difference in performance between that and a mobile phone such as Android or iPhone.
First of all, its probably going to be a good while before we see anything like a 500MHz 060... (if ever, depends how it goes..FPGA cost goes up for the pro stuff)
Secondly... Well, in theory, you could build a new system based on that and have great programmers produce fantastic stuff (relatively speaking)..
In the realm known as "reality" however, we can barely find 400 ppl to fund a kickstarter for new Amiga cases, and where are all these great programmers that will write this fantastic software. All new computers have to face the chicken and the egg problem at some point. (for programmers to earn money there has to be a large user base of paying customers, and the large user base is usually "created" with good software)
However, putting that aside. The Amiga 68k hardware will not be able to compete with the NG Amiga system such as X1000 or modern x86 motherboard for those latest 3D heavy intensive games like battlefield, oblivion, etc nor will it ever be. What me personally I am looking for, in my Amiga classic system...is ability to browse the net using OWB and run 80% of the website online in my classic system, watch youtube, watch movies, and run DOSBox. If I can go do that...personally I have reached my goal in what I want to use my classic Amiga even though I could already do all of this in my x86 and better.
Well, there you go. This "what defines the classic Amiga for you personally" -is a never ending discussion in these forums. Nostalgia is not about logic, ppl use it for different stuff and different reasons. Your last lines kind of nails the "what for?" issue when you talk about doing modern stuff on an old platform. Browsing, youtube etc will never be as good as on a modern PC, so why bother, right? Keep the retro system for doing its own thing, not trying to pretend its a modern computer that can compete on equal terms.
By now I hope we havent derailed the topic completely, it is still about what to do with the Vampire once its released. Anyhoo, I sugggest we take any further discussions about the future Amigas into a new thread, ok?
Cheers
/eX